How to Talk to Someone at a Bar Without It Being Awkward

HENRYS card game on a night out at a bar

Here's the funny thing about running a card game that tells everyone to meet people in person: eventually, you have to actually do it yourself.

We say it all day. Get off the apps, make the first move, go say hi. And not long ago, one of us had a slightly uncomfortable realization. For this business to work, we had to put our money where our mouth is and do the thing we personally find hardest, without needing a few drinks first.

So last weekend, one of us (hi, it's Kayla) walked up to a guy at a bar and said, hey, I just wanted to come introduce myself, I'm Kayla. It turned out she already knew him. They'd met six months earlier, he'd completely changed his hair, and he was wearing very dark glasses, so she genuinely didn't recognize him. He probably thought she was drunk. She texted him afterwards to say it was so funny running into him and she hoped he had a good rest of his night, and she gave herself full credit for walking over anyway.

Because that's the point. Talking to someone at a bar is almost never as awkward as it feels in your head, and even when it is, you survive it. Here's how to do it.

Before you go over: read the room (barely)

You don't need to be fluent in body language. Most of the time you can just tell the vibe.

And honestly, if it's a Thursday, Friday or Saturday night at a bar, assume people are open to being approached. The only exception is someone who looks visibly deep in the most serious conversation of their entire life. If the person you approach turns out to have a partner, that's fine too. They should be flattered, and you didn't know.

Openers that actually work

Confession: we've never really had an opener not work. The only step that matters is the first one, going from two strangers standing in silence to two strangers who are talking. What you say matters far less than the fact that you said something.

A few that have worked for us:

  • Hi, I just wanted to come introduce myself. Simple, a little bold, impossible to get wrong.
  • We're playing a game and it just dared me to come talk to you. It's the truth, and it explains everything.
  • Want to be on my team? This one comes straight from a card in our deck: find the stranger most likely to be the lead in a rom-com and ask them to join the game as your teammate.
  • The ridiculous one. While filming our dare series, the silliest dares got the best reactions, mostly because we couldn't keep a straight face. Laughing breaks the ice faster than any line. Once you explain it's a game with dares, people relax, and half the time they end up doing the dare with you.

When it goes badly (and why that's fine)

Worst case, they're not interested. That can be for so many reasons: you're not their type, they already have a partner, or they've got their own stuff going on. Rejection is never really about you. It's about the situation.

It takes practice, but you can train yourself to see it that way. We also believe rejection is redirection, and the more often you say hi to people, the easier it gets. Right now, everyone is starved for connection. Most people are much happier that you came over than you'd expect.

Moving it on without it being weird

If you're both enjoying the conversation, just ask: do you want to exchange Instagrams or numbers? Lead with it. Don't wait for them to say it first.

We've all had the night where neither person said anything and you went home with a what if. If you can sense a vibe and you're both enjoying talking, assume there's something there, and ask.

Or let a card do the hard part

If a nervous friend asked us for one piece of advice before walking over, we'd tell them to play HENRYS. Biased, but true.

One of us has struggled with this for years. Not low confidence, more a big ego around dating: letting someone know you're interested makes you vulnerable to the chance that they're not. That's exactly why a game helps. When a card dares you to go over, it isn't you putting yourself out there. It's the game.

HENRYS is a dating card game for nights out: a spicy version of Bullshit with truths, dares and nine dating archetypes you have definitely met, and plenty of the dares will send you straight over to the cute person across the bar. Shop HENRYS

Life is too short to be scared of talking to people you think are cute. What's meant for you will find you, but there's that saying: if you're praying for a ride and the bus is pulling up, you still have to run to catch it. So when you see the bus, f***ing sprint.